BIOGRAPHY

Book review: Charles Darwin: Victorian Mythmaker by AN Wilson

The author tries to attack the fundamentals of Darwin’s great work on evolution. What he reveals is his own scientific ignorance, says Professor Steve Jones

Obsessed with conspiracy theories: a cartoon of Charles Darwin from Vanity Fair, 1871
Obsessed with conspiracy theories: a cartoon of Charles Darwin from Vanity Fair, 1871
GETTY IMAGES
The Sunday Times

‘Darwin was wrong” is an odd sentence with which to begin a biography of the great evolutionist — even if, in some instances, it is correct. Yes, Charles Darwin was mistaken about some things: the machinery of inheritance, for instance, or the age of the Earth, or sea-level changes in Scotland and the function of fish swim-bladders. But he was in distinguished company. Newton was wrong about quite a lot of things, as was Mendel, as was Einstein.

Even a biographer as distinguished as AN Wilson admits to having made a few errors in his time, for he converted (if that is the word) to atheism from Christianity, only to jump ship back to belief. (His reason seems somewhat unChristian: “I relish the notion that,